Black Noir emerges victorious, with the real Homelander torn to pieces. 100% Upvoted. In the end, Homelander never really had a chance. So even though Queen Maeve is based on Wonder Woman, who could actually give Superman a run for his money in the world of DC, the fact is Maeve can’t so much as make Homelander flinch, as seen in The Boys #63 when she attacks him and winds up losing her head - literally. PS5: What You Should Do First With The New Console. Still, while Black Noir may have beaten Homelander in as straight of a one-on-one fight as fans could ever have hoped for, he's injured badly enough that Butcher, whose strength and durability is enhanced in the comics, is able to finish the job with the help of a team of marines and some heavy ordnance. Round 3:Black Noir vs Superman. Leave a Comment on Black Noir Vs. Butcher, Homelander Vs. HomeLander and Black Noir at there full power vs Trion Juggernaut. However, Noir isn’t looking much better; it clearly took everything he had to put Homelander down. Email mitchapman14@gmail.com if you have something you’d like to see featured. By clicking 'enter', you agree to GameSpot's Then A-train and Black Noir joins in. Battle. Round 4:Batman vs Homelander Without his amazing level of commitment to taking down the superheroes that ruined his life and his death wish, there wouldn’t be much of a show, as we saw in the first episode this season, when Butcher was largely absent. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. However, while Black Noir might seem like a Batman ripoff at first glance, his role in the overall narrative of The Boys is a lot more complex. Warning: The below article features spoilers for both The Boys Season 2 (up through Episode 7) and the comics on which The Boys is based. ( Log Out / Darth Vader: Anakin Knows Slaughtering The Younglings Was His Darkest Act. Homelander vs. Black Noir: Who Would Win A Fight To The Death? Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. In the comics, Black Noir is a clone of Homelander, created by Vought as a last-ditch safety measure should Homelander need to be put down. The other plots are fine, there’s just not a whole lot to them. Noir has been by Homelander's side for so long, unable to fulfill his singular purpose in life as long as Homelander stays relatively in line, that it drives him mad. Black Noir versus Butcher is the other really interesting arc this episode, as Noir tracks Butcher to his aunt’s house, which he visits after losing his motivation to fight superheroes last episode, when his wife refuses to leave Vought’s compound. It makes me wonder if Vought is hiding something more powerful than Homelander, or if they have some failsafe against him in case he goes out of control. As such, he has to find his mojo again this episode, as Hughie (Jack Quaid) and Mother’s Milk (Laz Alonso) do their best to save him from Noir. Terms of Use and All Bloodlusted. Michael Rougeau Noir also seems even more mentally unstable than Homelander, which would likely translate to him being even more brutal in a fight. Though Homelander has similar powers like eye laser, flight, super strength, etc. But we know virtually nothing about him, besides a vague sense of his powers (standard fare including super strength and an inhuman tolerance for pain) and the fact that he has either a naive soft side, or a sick sense of humor. Black Noir is played by Nathan Mitchell, a Black actor. Do you think its also the case in the show? There’s also the fact that Black Noir was made for the sole purpose of killing Homelander if the need ever arose, so he’s likely been preparing for their showdown all his life. on October 6, 2020 at 4:33PM PDT. Created as a contingency in case the original Homelander ever went insane, Black Noir has secretly been manipulating the entire story behind the scenes. Season 2 further highlights that “The Boys” really wasn’t suited for a weekly release schedule, as the show’s story feels more like a really long movie than an episodic adventure. Sorry, but you can't access this content! In the comics, Black Noir is a clone of Homelander, created by Vought as a last-ditch safety measure should Homelander need to be put down. That would seem to make sense for the character, despite Homelander at one point this season stating that Noir "doesn't identify as any particular race." For those familiar with the twist in the comics, this partial unmasking is rather convincing proof that the show will ultimately take the character in a different direction. In fact, Black Noir is able to pose as Homelander--which he does throughout the comics series, committing heinous atrocities while wearing Homelander's costume in order to try and speed along his leader's downfall. Change ). For now, we simply don't have enough information to guess whether The Boys will entirely or even partially adapt this particular twist from the comic books. Spoilers ahead. Superman has a better intensity of those powers… he easily catches Planes, moves as fast as Flash, flies in outer space. Privacy Policy, Now Playing: The Boys Season 2 Episode 7 "Butcher, Baker, Candlestick Maker" Breakdown & Theories, Got a news tip or want to contact us directly? In the end, only one of them is left standing. HomeLander and Black Noir at there full power vs Trion Juggernaut. While the two are matched in power, Black Noir is a feral maniac who has wanted to slaughter Homelander for years, while his originator is a pampered bully who was never expecting to have to meet his match. Want us to remember this setting for all your devices? Butcher’s arc is tragic because he just can’t win; He never would have found his wife had he not gone down his warpath, but said warpath molded him into somebody his wife couldn’t be with. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Who Is The Most Powerful Sorcerer Supreme in Marvel Comics? Black Noir could still be a clone of Homelander, or at least contain elements of Homelander's DNA, but have a different appearance--who knows what Vought's scientists are capable of? I googled a little about the comics and so there was info that Black Noir is basically a copy of Homelander in case Homelander goes rogue? Happily, with the Boys around, neither villain actually gets to walk away from their final battle. You need a javascript enabled browser to watch videos. We don't even know if Noir will recover from having almonds shoved into his mouth. View all posts by Mitchell Chapman. Mr. Edgar (Giancarlo Esposito), Vought’s president, fills the role Madelyn Stillwell did last season as Homelander’s handler, and despite having very strong disagreements with him, Homelander obeys him absolutely. The comics have the answer. Round 2:Batman and Black Noir vs Homelander and Superman. Butcher is a broken man, and while I think the show needs him because without him, our heroes have no teeth, I don’t think his story will end well. “The Boys” has a fairly large cast, and you might have around five different stories going on at the same time in each episode. Despite the fact that other characters from The Boys also have DC counterparts, they are still nowhere near Homelander’s power level. Season 2 further highlights that “The Boys” really wasn’t suited for a weekly release schedule, as the show’s story feels more like a really long movie than an episodic adventure. While the two are matched in power, Black Noir is a feral maniac who has wanted to slaughter Homelander for years, while his originator is a pampered bully who was never expecting to have to meet his match. share. What makes the show interesting is that these stories collide, merge, and create interesting scenarios, and Season 2 Episode 5 is no different. It was Black Noir - not Homelander - who raped Butcher’s wife, and who heightens the entire conflict between the Seven and the Boys so he will be given the green light to take Homelander’s place. The real Homelander’s record is far from spotless, but he still doesn’t take too kindly to being framed, and a fight ensues. His character definitely is a mistery after 1st season. This episode sees Homelander (Antony Starr) lose control over his public image when a video of him killing an innocent bystander surfaces online and incites protests against him; Billy Butcher (Karl Urban) visits his aunt’s house and almost gets killed by Black Noir (Nathan Mitchell); Vought tries to make Queen Maeve (Dominique McElligott) and Elena (Nicola Correia-Damude), her girlfriend, the face of the LGBTQ community; Kimiko (Karen Fukuhara) becomes an assassin; Stormfront (Aya Cash) is on to Starlight’s (Erin Moriarty) plot against Vought; and The Deep (Chase Crawford) gets married. We’ll probably see more of them next episode. Related: The Boys: Could Homelander Be Taken Down By Superman? Lastly, there's the scar tissue we glimpsed in this episode. How does this relate to the show revealing part of his face? For two seasons, Black Noir has remained the most mysterious character on Amazon's superhero send-up The Boys. Homelander is practically undisputed as the strongest supe in the Boys, but could he be taken down by Black Noir? Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out / Who is Miles Morales in Marvel’s Spider-Man: Miles Morales? His hobbies include creative writing, reading, gaming, and constantly re-watching the Marvel movies. 1 comment. There have been some other hints throughout Season 2, as well. ( Log Out / Even if Black Noir isn't a direct clone of Homelander in the show, his purpose--a panic button Vought can hit if they need Homelander eliminated--could still be the same. For example, there's the fact that Black Noir appears to be Stan Edgar's personal lapdog--Vought's CEO sends the sneaky supe on secret missions and watches everything he does through a personal bodycam. In fact, when it comes to the question of who would win in a fight between the two, the comics have already provided a pretty ironclad answer - and it may surprise you. By And their plight is what brings Butcher back, at least for now. Could X-Men's Gambit Really Hurt Galactus? ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. © 2020 GAMESPOT, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. A four-year veteran of the media industry, he works full-time at New England Newspapers Inc. as a page designer/copy editor and freelance writer. That sounds like a lot, and it is. Still, it’s little surprise Black Noir came out on top. The World | “The Boys” Season 2, Episode 5: “We Gotta Go Now” Review. In The Boys #65, it’s revealed that Black Noir has actually been a Homelander clone all along. Close • Posted by 36 minutes ago. Homelander's mindscape is made up of nothing but neuroses, self-doubt, unresolved issues, and anxieties. Homelander is designed to be a twisted, sadistic version of Superman, with all the Man of Steel’s powers - flight, strength, incredible durability, super senses, and devastating heat vision - but none of his moral fiber. Well, it's simple: If Black Noir is an exact copy of Homelander, then he certainly shouldn't have dark skin. Battle. Email news@gamespot.com. Homelander, the show’s Superman-wannabe, is still under Vought’s thumb, despite killing their vice president last season. Jameson Is The Only Enemy Who Knows Spider-Man's Bizarre Weakness. The World | “The Boys” Season 2, Episode 5: “We Gotta Go Now” Review, Explaining Social Media’s Subtle Brainwashing | “The Social Dilemma” 2020 Netflix Movie Review, A Star-Studded, Character-Driven Period Piece | “The Devil All the Time” 2020 Netflix Movie Review, Follow InReview: Reviews, Commentary and More on WordPress.com, A Huge Mess | "The Seven Deadly Sins" Season 4 "Wrath of the Gods" 2020 Netflix Anime Series English Dub Review, Death By Algorithm | "Retro Bowl" Seasons 1-5 Mobile Game Review [Free Version], Beyond Pay-To-Win Mechanics | "Retro Bowl" Seasons 6-32 Mobile Game Review [Free Version], 5 Ways to Improve the Star Wars Franchise | Column from the Editor, Reignite the "Legend of Spyro" Trilogy | Column from the Editor, A (Mostly) Accurate Thanksgiving Movie | 'Knives Out' Movie Review, A Pokemon Hack Clearly Worth The Time To Play | "Pokemon: Crystal Clear" Game Review, The "High School Musical" Trilogy Isn't Nearly As Terrible As I Remembered | "High School Musical" 1, 2 & 3 Retro Movie Reviews in Brief, The Berkshire County movie you never knew about, One Year In, Disney Plus Isn't Worth It | Column from the Editor, Top 10 Best Maps In Gaming | Column from the Editor, Top 10 Lackluster Boss Fights In Gaming | Column from the Editor, Top 10 Best Boss Fights In Gaming | Column from the Editor, Ushering In A New Era: Anticipating The PS5 And Recapping the PS4 | Column from the Editor, Delivering On Its Promise | “SpongeBob SquarePants: Battle for Bikini Bottom – Rehydrated” Video Game Review, Classic Burton | “Beetlejuice” 1988 Movie Review, A Simple Film | “A Simple Wish” 1997 Movie Review, Men Ruined Ghostbusters | “Ghostbusters” 2016 Movie Review, The Changing Landscape Of Cinema During COVID-19 | Column from the Critic, An Underappreciated Performance | “Shattered Glass” 2003 Movie Review, “What kind of cop are you?” | “Disco Elysium” 2019 Video Game Review, “Vampire: The Masquerade” Meets “The Office” | “What We Do in the Shadows” Season 1 TV Series Review, Hell, Gods and Father Issues | “Hades” Early Access Video Game Review, Buggy and By the Numbers but Decent, Cheap, and Kinda Fun | “Terminator Resistance” Video Game Review, ‘Binding of Isaac meets Hearthstone’ | ‘Slay the Spire’ Video Game Review, Dealing With Filoni’s Mandalore Canon | “The Mandalorian” Season 2, Episode 3 “The Heiress” Review, One Year In, Disney Plus Isn’t Worth It | Column from the Editor, The Reinvention of the Screw | “The Haunting of Bly Manor” 2020 Netflix Series Review, Let’s Talk About Those Weird Baby Yoda Scenes From “The Mandalorian” Season 2, Episode 2 | Column from the Editor, What Biden’s Win Could Mean For The Entertainment Industry | Column from the Editor, Touchstone Meets Disney Plus | “Splash” 1984 Retro Movie Review (Disney Plus Version), InReview’s 2020 Oscar Predictions | Staff Picks, InReview’s 2020 Printable Oscar Predictions Ballot, Best of the 2010s in Gaming | The Revvies Awards: Decade Edition, The First Annual Revvies: Best of the Year in Gaming | 2019 InReview Site Awards. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. “The Boys” Season 2, Episode 5 gets a 7/10, Mitchell Chapman is the owner and editor of InReview. You've Never Heard of the Avengers' Most Powerful Enemy. Homelander Sexually Harasses Starlight The difference between this scene and in the Amazon TV series is that Homelander is the one who forces himself on Starlight, not the Deep. On the surface, the darkness-themed supe with ninja-like powers is a clear parody of Batman, especially given his place in the trifecta of Black Noir, Homelander (Superman), and Queen Maeve (Wonder Woman). No, without kryptonite. Mitchell has written arts reviews for various publications over the years, including The MCLA Beacon, Hubpages, Her Campus, The Odyssey, The Huffington Post and Goomba Stomp. While Homelander always relied solely on his powers to win battles, Black Noir has all the same abilities plus actual combat training. Log in or sign up to leave a comment log in sign up. on Black Noir Vs. Butcher, Homelander Vs. He has written for publications such as Silverpen Productions, PreLaw Land, and Clifton Park Neighbors Magazine. Butcher’s character is interesting, as he’s become this bloodthirsty, relentlessly violent person to go toe to toe with the supes, but in doing so, he has adopted a prejudice against them that has made him completely incompatible with his wife, who bore and is caring for Homelander’s son. The Boys: Could Homelander Be Taken Down By Superman? This is his third tour of duty blogging, having previously maintained a blog in high school as well as the Berkshire Eagle entertainment blog "The Way of the Sith." I just finished the show and I was really curious about Homelander and even more about Black Noir. The show goes so far as to show Homelander imagining killing them, which makes me believe he will commit an atrocity so great all public support for him will evaporate by season’s end. A one-stop shop for all things video games. That's because of a specific twist in the comics that's so awesome, fans can't help but hope that it gets adapted in the show. Click the button below to start this article in quick view. More: The Boys: Homelander Can Be Defeated Using An Obscure Superman Weakness. Eddie is a recent graduate of Skidmore College. That could mean that Black Noir's origin story is completely different from the comics, or that something went awry during his creation. An alumnus of the Massachusetts College of Liberal arts, he is the former editor-in-chief of the school newspaper, The Beacon, and has also served as the paper’s arts & entertainment editor, features editor, managing editor and business manager. He has all the same powers as Homelander… It makes you wonder what exactly is stopping him from killing everyone at Vought and doing whatever he wants. So although it didn't seem like much on the surface, it was a big deal when, during Black Noir's fight with Starlight at Vought Tower in Episode 7, we finally caught a small glimpse of Noir's face. Butcher finds his motivation this episode, which really is the driving force behind this show. ( Log Out / This is your final warning. When Maeve pulls Noir's mask up, if you look closely, you can clearly see that the skin around Noir's jaw is severely scarred--almost like Deadpool's in that character's live-action incarnation. That said, fans have always assumed that Mitchell's role could just be a guy in a suit, and that if the show reached the point of revealing Black Noir's face, the character would look very different from the actor who plays him currently. Maeve pulled up the bottom of Noir's cowl so she could shove an Almond Joy in his mouth, in the process revealing some things about the supe and throwing some fan expectations into chaos. In other words, it's a playground for any half-competent telepath, let alone the Martian Manhunter.